Recalculating: in education, still the same destination but we are lost and need a new route.

by Gabriel Rshaid

In what is perhaps one of the most prescient examples of the frenetic obsolescence rhythm of technology, GPSs, now irreversibly embedded in smart phones, did mark an era. From having to rely on maps and a sometimes elusive sense of direction, this almost miraculous technology freed us completely from finding a way, thus allowing us to concentrate on the driving to make sure that we got to the right destination.

But even this most efficient and seamless of technologies still relied on human judgment to negotiate the right road, thus giving rise to an idiosyncratic moment: when a turn was missed or the wrong option made, only to find that we were lost, signaled by the dreaded “Recalculating…”, while the ineffable device calculated a new route with its heartless and dispassionate patience.

At this point in time, education is a similar moment. Unbeknownst to us, we have taken not one but many wrong turns, even though the destination still remains the same, we are lost and badly in the need to recalculate our route.

The end of the journey remains unaltered, as attested by a multitude of mission statements which, in different forms, metaphors and phrases, have always gotten it right, expressing, in an almost schizophrenic self-case study, all that we seek to accomplish but are seemingly clueless as to how to do it: these statements speak about lifelong learning, values, helping young people rise to their full potential, become creative, open to new ideas, embrace globalization, and a long litany of other beautiful catchphrases.

To support my case, I’ve copied mission statements from 62 different schools and school districts, public and private, from all levels, from the site https://www.missionstatements.com and compiled them into a word cloud, depicting the broad range of these well-intentioned statements:

(the only word edited out of the cloud is “school” which would obviously otherwise become the most prominent in the picture)

But, as anybody spending time in a school would readily attest, reality is very different. Notably absent from the image are some of the words that convey what really happens in schools. Tests, standards, numeric grades, homework, academics, labeling, are just a few examples of how we seemingly have lost our bearing, and need to find a different route if we are ever to get close to achieving what we say we want for our students.

Simply stated, these are some of the wrong turns that have inadvertently been made over the years and the new road that needs to be taken:

Wrong turn New road
Sit down, closed book, fixed time, end of unit written test, no retest allowed. Open book, flexible time, formative, authentic assessment not limited to written tests.
Individual work Collaborative work
Assessment as judgment of students Assessment as an integral part of the learning process
Technology within learning management systems that mostly digitize the traditional model Technology as a positive disruption factor using games, simulations, online collaborative projects
Teacher centered Student centered
Students as passive recipients of their education Students assuming responsibility and managing their own learning
Learning contents Lifelong learning
Learning limited in space and time Continuous learning
Learning from adults Learning with adults and peers
Benefiting from the knowledge society Becoming active contributors to the knowledge society
Ignoring the online world Re-signifying positive initiatives in the online world
Paying lip service to creativity and higher-order thinking skills Developing intentional curricular interventions that foster the learning of creativity and higher order skills
School curricula based almost entirely on traditional academic syllabuses Opening up to the community, solving real-life problems
Top-down decision on curriculum Meeting students at their topics of interest
Students listening to teachers teach Students making projects, creating and designing
School curriculum almost entirely focused on academics A more encompassing education that includes wellness, nutrition, fitness habits for life and values and character education.
One-size-fits-all rigorous standards that all students have to comply with A more personalized assessment system that caters to each student’s individual range of abilities
Students not making grades fail Students learn from failure in a safe environment
Schools are accountable for the quality of the results obtained by their students Schools are accountable for promoting well-being and a high sense of self-esteem in their students

 

And so on and so forth. This list does not intend to become a new taxonomy of sorts, and it could, literally, be endless, since the number of wrong turns we have taken over the years, in a misguided attempt to render ourselves accountable for a dubious high-quality rigorous education, have already placed us almost beyond the ability of the proverbial GPS to recalculate.

But there is no GPS. We can’t rely on an impersonal all efficient algorithm that will take us out of our current confusion to guide us back onto the correct route. It is up to us. We educators need to shed away our political correctness, of what is possibly a collective global sense of insecurity as a profession, and do as we know is right. We are the only GPS we have, and it is time to recalculate. The table above is obviously not a set of ideas or thoughts of my own, but rather a loose compilation of principles that it would be very hard to disagree with and that I can say, with a high degree of certainty, expresses what educators feel all over the world, but, despite which, we find ourselves powerless to act upon.

The time is now. We can’t wait any longer. It is time to recalculate, take a new road, and not be apologetic about it.

 

I accept that my given data and my IP address is sent to a server in the USA only for the purpose of spam prevention through the Akismet program.More information on Akismet and GDPR.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.